Getting a letter or call that your at-home colon cancer screening test came back positive is unsettling. Even so, a positive result on a FIT kit or a stool DNA test (one brand is Cologuard) does not mean you have cancer. It means the test found something that needs a closer look, and the next step is a colonoscopy. That colonoscopy should be scheduled soon, not put off for months.
The most common at-home stool test for colorectal cancer screening is the FIT (fecal immunochemical test). It checks a stool sample for tiny amounts of human blood that you can’t see and is done once a year. A stool DNA test (multi-target stool DNA, or mt-sDNA) combines a check for hidden blood, like FIT, with a check for DNA changes that can come from cancer or precancerous polyps. People who use it usually repeat it every three years.
A newer stool RNA test checks for hidden blood and for RNA markers linked to cancer and precancerous polyps. The American Cancer Society added it as a preferred option in its May 2026 guideline update, repeated every three years.
All of these tests are screening tools that help sort out who needs a colonoscopy. They can’t tell you what caused the result or where in the bowel it came from. That is why a positive result calls for a closer look.
Many things besides cancer can trigger a positive result, because polyps can bleed or shed abnormal DNA. Hemorrhoids, small tears and inflammation in the bowel can put small amounts of blood in the stool as well. Sometimes the colonoscopy finds no clear cause at all.
Stool DNA tests in particular are more likely than FIT to flag people who turn out not to have cancer or advanced polyps. In the large study that led to approval of the first stool DNA test, about 13 out of 100 people without cancer or advanced precancerous polyps still got a positive result. For FIT, the figure was about 5 in 100. The same study found the DNA test detected more cancers than FIT.
A newer version of the stool DNA test did better in its own large study, published in 2024. In that study, about 9 in 100 people without cancer or advanced polyps got a positive result. Either way, the only way to know what a positive result means for you is to look inside the colon.
The American Cancer Society says any abnormal result on a stool-based screening test should be followed by a timely colonoscopy. The US Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer, a joint panel of the major GI medical societies, recommends colonoscopy after a positive FIT, not a repeat FIT.
Repeating the stool test is not a substitute, since a second negative kit doesn’t cancel out the first positive one. The guidelines above call for colonoscopy as the follow-up. Colonoscopy can treat a problem as well as find it. If polyps are the cause, they can usually be removed during the same procedure, which lowers the chance they ever become cancer. Think of the stool test as only the first half of your screening, which isn’t finished until the colonoscopy is done.
It’s common to put off a follow-up colonoscopy, especially if you feel fine. Most people with early colon cancer or polyps have no symptoms, so feeling well doesn’t tell you much about what is going on inside the colon.
A large study published in JAMA in 2017 suggests that timing does matter. It compared more than 70,000 people with a positive FIT by how long they waited before their colonoscopy. Compared with having a colonoscopy within 8 to 30 days, waiting 10 months or longer was linked to a higher risk of colorectal cancer. It was also linked to a higher chance that any cancer found was at a more advanced stage.
Shorter waits were not clearly linked to worse results in that study, but it was not designed to find a safe waiting period. There is no known benefit to waiting, and the safest plan is to schedule soon.
Most people go through the same six steps between a positive stool test and their results:
Fear is one of the most common reasons people delay a follow-up colonoscopy. Keep in mind that a positive stool test leads, in many cases, to finding and removing polyps, which is exactly what screening is meant to do. When cancer is found through screening, it is more often at an earlier stage, when treatment works better.
Seek emergency care right away if you have heavy rectal bleeding, black or tarry stools, dizziness or fainting, or severe belly pain, even if your stool test was normal.
Book a colonoscopy visit soon if you have:
GI Associates performs follow-up colonoscopies after positive stool tests at its clinics in Wausau, Stevens Point and Wisconsin Rapids, and our team can explain each step. If your test came back positive, request an appointment so the colonoscopy can be scheduled soon.
This article is for general education and is not a substitute for medical advice. Talk with your doctor about your test results and before changing any medication.